Choosing the right front entry door is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when upgrading or building your home. Not only does your front door set the tone for your home’s curb appeal, but it also plays a crucial role in security, energy efficiency, and long-term maintenance.
At NorthShield, we specialize in providing high-quality, Canadian-made fibreglass doors and steel entry doors tailored to suit your style, budget, and climate needs. Whether you’re replacing an old door or selecting one for a new build, both fibreglass and steel are excellent choices, each with its own unique advantages.
Let’s dive into what makes these two materials so popular and how they compare so you can decide which one is best for your home in Toronto or Winnipeg.
What Are Fibreglass Doors?
Fibreglass entry doors are constructed using a wood or composite frame that’s wrapped in a layer of moulded fibreglass. This outer shell is often designed to mimic real wood grain, offering the classic look of cedar, oak, mahogany, and more, without the maintenance concerns associated with natural wood.
These doors are typically filled with polyurethane foam, giving them superior insulation properties and making them a top choice for energy-conscious homeowners.
Pros of Fibreglass Doors:
- Excellent energy efficiency: High R-values help reduce heating and cooling costs.
- Low maintenance: Resists warping, cracking, rotting, and rusting.
- Stylish options: Available in many wood-like finishes and custom paint colours.
- Durable: Withstands extreme weather conditions common in Canadian climates.
- Secure: Reinforced frames provide strong protection against forced entry.
Cons of Fibreglass Doors:
- Higher upfront cost: More expensive than basic steel doors.
- Can chip or crack: Especially under heavy impact.
- Limited customization: Some models cannot be trimmed or resized after installation.
What Are Steel Doors?
Steel entry doors are made by wrapping a wood or composite frame in a thin layer of galvanized steel. These doors are known for their strength and affordability, making them a go-to option for homeowners prioritizing security and budget-friendliness.
While not as naturally insulating as fibreglass, modern steel doors often include polyurethane cores to improve thermal performance and energy efficiency.
Pros of Steel Doors:
- Cost-effective: Generally cheaper than fibreglass doors.
- Very secure: Extremely difficult to break through; ideal for safety-focused homes.
- Fire-resistant: Offers added protection in certain situations.
- Durable: Won’t warp or shrink like wood.
Cons of Steel Doors:
- Prone to dents and scratches: Can show signs of wear over time.
- Susceptible to rust: If scratched and not repainted, moisture can cause corrosion.
- Less insulation: Without proper core fill, they’re less efficient than fibreglass.
- Cold to the touch: Especially noticeable in winter months.
Fibreglass VS Steel: Head-to-Head Comparison
When comparing fibreglass vs steel doors, it’s important to evaluate them across several key categories:
| FEATURE | FIBREGLASS | STEEL |
| Appearance | Superior wood-like finish with multiple colours and texture options. | Limited wood-grain appearance; more suited to modern or minimalist styles. |
| Durability | Resists warping, cracking, rusting, and UV damage. | Strong and durable, but susceptible to dents and rust if not maintained. |
| Energy Efficiency | Highly energy-efficient due to thick insulation cores. | Moderately efficient; depends on the quality of insulation used. |
| Security | Very secure, though slightly less resistant to brute force than steel. | Top-tier security; nearly impossible to kick in. |
| Maintenance | Virtually maintenance-free; occasional cleaning is all that’s needed. | Requires regular inspection for scratches and repainting when needed. |
| Cost | Higher initial investment, but offers long-term value. | Budget-friendly upfront cost, but may need earlier replacement. |
| Installation | Lighter weight makes installation easier. | Heavier; requires reinforced framing and careful mounting. |
When Is Fibreglass the Best Choice?
Fibreglass doors are ideal for homeowners who want a combination of style, insulation, and longevity. They are especially well-suited for:
- Homes in cold climates (like Manitoba and Ontario), where energy efficiency matters.
- Homeowners looking for wood-like aesthetics without the upkeep.
- Those seeking low-maintenance solutions that won’t require frequent painting or repairs.
- Properties where curb appeal and resale value are priorities.
However, fibreglass may not be the best option if:
- Your budget is tight, and you’re looking for the most affordable entry door.
- You live in an area where the door might be subject to heavy impact (e.g., near a busy street or playground).
If you choose a fibreglass door, NorthShield offers a wide range of customizable options and expert installation services to ensure lasting performance and beauty.
When Is Steel the Best Choice?
Steel doors are a solid pick for homeowners focused on security, affordability, and simplicity. They work well for:
- First-time buyers or rental property owners looking for cost-effective upgrades.
- Homes needing high-security entryways, such as urban areas or ground-level units.
- Contemporary-style homes where a sleek, modern look is preferred.
- Anyone wanting a durable, no-fuss solution that will last for decades with proper care.
That said, steel may not be the best fit if:
- You’re concerned about rust and corrosion, especially in humid or coastal regions.
- You prioritize energy efficiency and want the lowest possible utility bills.
- You prefer the look of real wood or want a variety of design choices.
- NorthShield ensures every steel door is professionally installed with reinforced frames and protective coatings to maximize durability and longevity.
Both fibreglass and steel doors offer significant benefits, and the right choice ultimately comes down to your specific needs, preferences, and budget. Whether you’re looking for timeless elegance, energy savings, or unbeatable security, NorthShield Windows and Doors has the perfect entry door solution for your Southern Ontario or Winnipeg home.
Our team specializes in helping homeowners select, customize, and install high-performance entry doors that enhance both function and style.
Ready to upgrade your front entrance? Contact us today to schedule a consultation or request a free quote. Let NorthShield guide you toward the best door for your home.